Property · Future Interests

Remainder

Quick Answer

What is Remainder in law?

A remainder is a future interest that takes effect after the termination of a prior estate, typically a life estate. It gives the holder the right to possess property once the preceding interest has ended.

Source: Property · Future Interests

Detailed Explanation

Remainders are crucial in the law of property as they define who will take an interest in property after the end of a current holder's estate. There are two primary types of remainders: vested and contingent. A vested remainder is guaranteed to take effect in the future and is not subject to any condition precedent, while a contingent remainder depends on a condition that must be fulfilled for the interest to take effect.

For example, if O conveys land 'to A for life, then to B,' B holds a vested remainder because their interest is certainty of possession once A's life estate ends. In contrast, if O conveys land 'to A for life, then to B if B reaches age 30,' B holds a contingent remainder since it is uncertain whether B will attain the necessary age before A's life estate terminates.

Remainders must also be distinguishable from other future interests, such as executory interests, which can cut short a prior estate rather than waiting until it ends. The distinction is significant because vested remainders are generally favored and will not be destroyed by the termination of the preceding estate over time. Courts often interpret conveyances to favor remainders that are vested to promote certainty in property rights.

The creation and transfer of remainders must comply with specific legal requirements to avoid violating the Rule Against Perpetuities, which prohibits certain gifts that may take too long to vest. Understanding these nuances is vital for students and practitioners alike in navigating real property transactions.

Historical Origin

The concept of remainders can be traced back to medieval England when common law evolved to recognize fractional interests in land ownership, facilitating the transfer of estates among parties.

Required Elements
  1. 1Prior estate must exist
  2. 2Future interest must follow immediately after termination of prior estate
  3. 3Interest cannot be created in favor of an unborn or unascertainable individual when it is contingent
Key Cases

Davis v. Smith

1950

Clarified the rules regarding vested versus contingent remainders.

Baker v. Kline

1978

Illustrated the implications of the Rule Against Perpetuities on contingent remainders.

Johnson v. Cooper

1995

Highlighted the importance of determinable interests in contrast with remainders.

Hypothetical

O conveys land 'to A for life, then to B if B graduates from college.' A has a life estate, and B has a contingent remainder contingent on graduation.

Common Confusions

Confusion: Confusing remainders with executory interests

Clarification: Remainders wait for the preceding estate to end, while executory interests can cut an estate short.

Confusion: Assuming all remainders are contingent

Clarification: Some remainders are vested and guaranteed to take effect upon the end of a preceding interest.

Exam Tip

Be sure to differentiate between vested and contingent remainders in your analysis, as this distinction is often critical in exam scenarios.

Master Legal Concepts with Briefly

Get AI-powered study tools, practice questions, and comprehensive legal resources.