What Are The Defenses To Conversion in Torts?

Defenses to conversion include consent, necessity, and the absence of wrongful intent. These defenses can absolve or mitigate liability for the tort of conversion.

In tort law, conversion is a voluntary act that deprives an owner of their property without consent. Various defenses can negate liability for conversion claims. One such defense is consent, which holds that if the property owner has given permission to use the property, this negates a conversion claim. For example, if a friend borrows a car with permission and later damages it, they may argue that they had the owner's consent to use the vehicle.

Another common defense is necessity, where a defendant may argue that taking or using someone else's property was necessary to prevent greater harm. For instance, breaking into a neighbor's shed to retrieve a hose to put out a fire could be justified under necessity, provided it was a true emergency.

Absence of wrongful intent is also a viable defense. If the defendant can prove that they honestly believed they had a right to the property, or that the act was not intentional but rather accidental, this might absolve them from liability. For example, if a person mistakenly takes a car they believe is theirs, they may successfully defend against conversion.

There are also related defenses depending on jurisdiction or specific circumstances, such as the statute of limitations, which protects defendants if a claim is not timely filed. Overall, the success of these defenses often hinges on the particular facts of each case and the jurisdiction's interpretations of conversion and associated defenses.

• 1Garratt v. Dailey (1955) - established that intent can be met through the knowledge that an act would likely result in interference with another's possession.
• 2Moore v. Regents of the University of California (1990) - consent can serve as a defense when the owner grants permission for the use of property.
• 3Vincent v. Lake Erie Transportation Co. (1880) - necessity as a defense was recognized where private injury results from actions taken to prevent greater harm.

• what-is-conversion-in-torts
• how-to-prove-conversion
• what-are-the-elements-of-conversion