Joint Tenancy vs Tenancy in Common
What is the Joint Tenancy vs Tenancy in Common?
Joint tenancy features the right of survivorship (the surviving tenant automatically inherits the deceased tenant's share), while tenancy in common has no survivorship -- each tenant's share is freely devisable and inheritable.
Definition
Joint tenancy and tenancy in common are the two principal forms of concurrent ownership of real property. The fundamental distinction is the right of survivorship: in a joint tenancy, when one joint tenant dies, that tenant's interest automatically passes to the surviving joint tenant(s) by operation of law, outside of probate. In a tenancy in common, each tenant holds a separate, undivided interest that passes to the tenant's heirs or devisees upon death.
At common law, creating a joint tenancy required the four unities: time (all interests must vest at the same time), title (all interests must arise from the same instrument), interest (all tenants must hold equal shares of the same type of estate), and possession (all tenants must have equal rights to possess the whole property). If any unity was lacking, the estate was a tenancy in common. Modern law presumes a tenancy in common in most jurisdictions, and creating a joint tenancy requires clear and express language indicating the intent to create a right of survivorship.
A joint tenancy can be severed (converted to a tenancy in common) by any joint tenant's unilateral action, such as conveying the interest to a third party, executing a mortgage (in title theory states), or obtaining a judicial partition. Severance destroys the right of survivorship. A tenancy in common, by contrast, cannot be 'severed' because there is no survivorship right to destroy. Both joint tenants and tenants in common have the right to partition -- the division of the property either physically (partition in kind) or through a forced sale (partition by sale).
Key Elements
- 1Joint tenancy requires the four unities: time, title, interest, and possession (TTIP)
- 2Joint tenancy features the right of survivorship; tenancy in common does not
- 3Modern presumption favors tenancy in common; joint tenancy requires express language
- 4Joint tenancy can be severed unilaterally, converting it to tenancy in common
- 5Both co-tenancies allow partition (in kind or by sale)
- 6Each co-tenant has the right to possess and use the entire property
Landmark Cases
Riddle v. Harmon
102 Cal. App. 3d 524 (1980)
Held that a joint tenant can unilaterally sever the joint tenancy by conveying to themselves, eliminating the common-law requirement of using a strawman intermediary.
Harms v. Sprague
105 Ill. 2d 215 (1984)
Held that in a lien theory state, a mortgage by one joint tenant does not sever the joint tenancy, and the mortgage is extinguished upon the mortgaging tenant's death.
Delfino v. Vealencis
181 Conn. 533 (1980)
Addressed the preference for partition in kind over partition by sale, holding that a forced sale should be ordered only when physical partition is impracticable or would result in great prejudice.
Tenhet v. Boswell
18 Cal. 3d 150 (1976)
Held that a lease by one joint tenant does not sever the joint tenancy and that the lease terminates upon the death of the leasing joint tenant.
Exam Tips
- Always check for the four unities (TTIP) when analyzing whether a joint tenancy exists. If any unity is missing, the result is a tenancy in common.
- Severance is a major exam topic. Know what acts sever a joint tenancy: conveyance to a third party always severs; mortgage severs only in title theory states; a lease generally does not sever.
- When one joint tenant dies, determine whether the joint tenancy was severed before death. If severed, the deceased tenant's share passes through probate. If not severed, it passes automatically to the survivor.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Assuming a mortgage always severs a joint tenancy -- it depends on whether the jurisdiction follows title theory (mortgage severs) or lien theory (mortgage does not sever).
- Forgetting that a joint tenant's will has no effect on the joint tenancy interest because the right of survivorship operates automatically, outside of probate.
Memory Aid
TTIP for the four unities: Time, Title, Interest, Possession. Joint = right of survivorship (the Joint survivor takes all).