Solicitation
What is the Solicitation?
Solicitation is the crime of asking, encouraging, or requesting another person to commit a crime, with the intent that the crime be committed. The offense is complete upon the asking, regardless of whether the other person agrees.
Definition
Solicitation is an inchoate offense that criminalizes the act of intentionally asking, inducing, encouraging, or commanding another person to commit a crime. The crime is complete the moment the solicitation is made, regardless of whether the solicited person agrees to commit the crime, makes any effort to do so, or even understands the request. The focus is entirely on the solicitor's conduct and intent.
The mens rea for solicitation requires the specific intent that the solicited crime be committed. Merely joking about committing a crime or making an idle threat does not constitute solicitation because the required intent is absent. The actus reus is the communication of the request or encouragement to another person. If the communication never reaches the intended recipient (e.g., an intercepted letter), most jurisdictions following common law would not find solicitation, though the MPC would still impose liability because the defendant completed the act of attempting to communicate.
Solicitation merges with the completed offense and with conspiracy. If the solicited person agrees to commit the crime, the solicitation merges into a conspiracy. If the crime is actually committed, the solicitor is liable as an accomplice. At common law, renunciation or withdrawal is not a defense to solicitation, because the crime was already complete upon the asking. Under the MPC, voluntary and complete renunciation is an affirmative defense if the solicitor thwarts the commission of the crime. Solicitation is typically graded as a lesser offense than the target crime.
Key Elements
- 1An intentional act of asking, encouraging, inducing, or commanding another to commit a crime
- 2Specific intent that the solicited crime actually be committed
- 3Communication of the solicitation to another person (under common law; MPC does not require receipt)
- 4The crime is complete upon the solicitation regardless of the response
Landmark Cases
State v. Cotton
790 P.2d 1050 (N.M. Ct. App. 1990)
Held that solicitation is complete upon the asking and does not require the solicited person to agree or act
People v. Lubow
29 N.Y.2d 58 (1971)
Clarified that solicitation requires genuine intent for the crime to be committed, not mere social commentary
United States v. Williams
553 U.S. 285 (2008)
Upheld federal solicitation statute against First Amendment challenge, distinguishing criminal solicitation from protected speech
Exam Tips
- Solicitation is complete the moment the request is made; no agreement or action by the solicited party is needed
- If the solicited party agrees, the crime shifts from solicitation to conspiracy; know the merger rules
- Watch for First Amendment issues: advocacy of illegal action in the abstract is protected speech, but direct solicitation of a specific crime is not
- Under the MPC, an uncommunicated solicitation (e.g., letter intercepted before delivery) can still be criminal
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Thinking that the solicited person must agree or take action for solicitation to be complete; it is complete upon the asking
- Confusing solicitation with conspiracy; solicitation is a one-sided request, while conspiracy requires a meeting of the minds
- Forgetting that solicitation merges into conspiracy (if the other party agrees) and into the substantive offense (if committed)
Memory Aid
"Asking is the crime" -- solicitation is complete the instant you ask, regardless of the answer