Maryland

Dillon v. Legg in Maryland Law

How Dillon v. Legg applies in Maryland: state-specific rules, key cases, and bar exam notes for Torts.

State Approach

Maryland follows the principles regarding bystander recovery articulated in Dillon v. Legg, allowing for emotional distress claims under certain circumstances. The courts assess the relationship between the plaintiff and the victim, as well as proximity to the incident.

State Rule
In Maryland, a bystander may recover for emotional distress if they witness the injury to a closely related person, are present at the scene, and the injury is the result of another's negligence.
Significant State Cases

Baker v. Baltimore

Recognized a bystander’s claim for emotional distress while reiterating the need for immediate proximity to the event.

Klein v. Eubanks

Allowed a claim for emotional distress from a parent witnessing the negligent injury to their child, following Dillon's rationale.

McCauley v. Pohlman

Articulated guidelines for bystander recovery, emphasizing the need for a direct relationship to the victim.

Comparison to Federal Law

Maryland's approach to emotional distress claims for bystanders closely parallels federal standards, particularly in adhering to foreseeability and the need for a close relationship. However, some Maryland courts impose stricter proximity requirements compared to the more lenient federal guidelines.

Bar Exam Note

The principles from Dillon v. Legg are relevant for the Maryland bar exam, particularly in the context of torts involving emotional distress and bystander claims.

Practice Pointers
  • Always establish the relational proximity between the plaintiff and the victim when discussing bystander claims.
  • Ensure the plaintiff was present at the scene to substantiate claims for emotional distress in Maryland.
  • Refer to relevant state precedents that bolster the argument for bystander recovery based on emotional distress.

Master State-Specific Law with Briefly

Get AI-powered state case analyses, bar exam prep, and comprehensive study tools.